Good Indoor air quality may improve lung function and creativity

Indoor air quality (IAQ) parameters include gas levels, airborne particulate matter like PM10 and PM2.5, microbial contaminants, and environmental factors including air temperature, humidity and air movement. Excessive exposure can cause health and psychological issues such as reduced productivity, sick-building syndrome, and impaired cognitive abilities, but there is little understanding of its impact on creativity. As creativity involves multiple cognitive processes, there may be a link between IAQ and creativity.

Shmitha Arikrishnan and colleagues recently studied creativity, a multi-faceted ability measured through divergent thinking. The SBP (Serious Brick Play) method, which uses LEGO bricks, provides a hands-on learning experience to quantify creative ability. This study used SBP to test the impact of IAQ on creativity and found that reducing TVOC concentration increased creativity score, but reducing PM2.5 and increasing ventilation rate did not show significant effects. The study was published in Scientific Reports.

Companies are increasingly seeking creative solutions to problems from their employees, but the office environment may hinder their creativity. This study evaluated the role of indoor air quality parameters (PM2.5, TVOC, and CO2) in fostering a creative environment using SBP, an adaptation of the LEGO Serious Play (LSP) framework. The study was conducted over six weeks in a simulated office space with 92 participants. Participants addressed challenges by building with Lego bricks and describing their solutions. The creations and descriptions were graded on originality, fluency, and creativity.

The results showed that higher TVOC levels were associated with lower-rated creative solutions. A 71.9% reduction in TVOC (from 1000 ppb) improved an individual’s full creative potential by 11.5%. Maintaining a low TVOC level will enhance creativity in offices.

This paper, which examines the link between IAQ pollutants and creativity, suggests ample scope for further research. The creativity study method was interactive and hands-on, not allowing individual cognitive processes to be explored. Future research should investigate the specific connection between pollutants and creativity. Although creative cognition is still new, non-invasive techniques like electroencephalography could help researchers study brain response, while SBP could help understand how playful, hands-on tests stimulate creativity.

Reference:

Arikrishnan, S.et al. Experimental study on the impact of indoor air quality on creativity by Serious Brick Play method. Sci Rep 13, 15488 (2023).

Powered by WPeMatico

DAPT de-escalation strategy suitable for stabilized MI patients with high ischemic risk: JAMA

South Korea: The de-escalation strategy is a reasonable and safe strategy option following myocardial infarction (MI) in patients with high ischemic risk, a recent study published in JAMA Cardiology has shown.

In the post hoc analysis of the TALOS-AMI randomized clinical trial, 1371 patients (50.8%) were categorized as having high ischemic risk. The researchers revealed that compared with ticagrelor-based dual antiplatelet therapy (DAPT), the bleeding and ischemic outcomes of an unguided de-escalation strategy were consistent, irrespective of high ischemic risk features, with no heterogeneity. TALOS-AMI is an open-label, assessor-blinded, multicenter, randomized clinical trial.

In patients with acute MI who have high ischemic risk, there is a lack of data on the safety and efficacy of the de-escalation strategy of switching from ticagrelor to clopidogrel. To fill this knowledge, Myunhee Lee, The Catholic University of Korea, Seoul, Republic of Korea, and colleagues aimed to evaluate the outcomes of the de-escalation strategy compared with DAPT with ticagrelor in stabilized patients with AMI and high ischemic risk following percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI).

The study included patients (mean age, 60.0 years; 16.8% female) with acute myocardial infarction (AMI) who had no event during 1 month of ticagrelor-based DAPT after PCI. Patients were randomly assigned to de-escalation from ticagrelor to clopidogrel or ticagrelor-based DAPT.

High ischemic risk was defined as having a history of chronic kidney disease or diabetes, at least 3 lesions treated, multivessel PCI, at least 3 stents implanted, total stent length greater than 60 mm, left main PCI, or bifurcation PCI with at least 2 stents.

The outcomes included ischemic outcomes (composite of cardiovascular death, ischemic stroke, myocardial infarction, stent thrombosis, or ischemia-driven revascularization) and bleeding outcomes (Bleeding Academic Research Consortium [BARC] type 2, 3, or 5 bleeding).

The study led to the following findings:

  • Of 2697 patients with AMI, 1371 (50.8%; 684 assigned to de-escalation and 687 assigned to ticagrelor-based DAPT) had high ischemic risk features and a significantly higher risk of ischemic outcomes than those without high ischemic risk (1326 patients [49.2%], including 665 assigned to de-escalation and 661 assigned to ticagrelor-based DAPT) (hazard ratio [HR], 1.74).
  • De-escalation to clopidogrel, compared with ticagrelor-based DAPT, showed no significant difference in ischemic risk across the high ischemic risk group (HR, 0.88) and the non–high ischemic risk group (HR, 0.65), without heterogeneity.
  • The bleeding risk of the de-escalation group was consistent in both the high ischemic risk group (HR, 0.64) and the non–high ischemic risk group (HR, 0.42), without heterogeneity.

“The findings suggest that in stabilized patients with acute MI, the bleeding and ischemic outcomes of an unguided de-escalation strategy with clopidogrel compared with a ticagrelor-based DAPT strategy were consistent without significant interaction, irrespective of the presence of high ischemic risk,” the researchers wrote.

Reference:

Lee M, Byun S, Lim S, et al. Dual Antiplatelet Therapy De-Escalation in Stabilized Myocardial Infarction With High Ischemic Risk: Post Hoc Analysis of the TALOS-AMI Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Cardiol. Published online December 20, 2023. doi:10.1001/jamacardio.2023.4587

Powered by WPeMatico

COVID-19 infection causes teen’s vocal cord paralysis in first-of-its-kind case

Physician-researchers from Mass Eye and Ear, a member of Mass General Brigham, report the first pediatric case of bilateral vocal cord paralysis after COVID-19 (SARS-CoV-2) infection. The patient, an otherwise healthy 15-year-old female, came to the emergency department at Massachusetts General Hospital with symptoms of respiratory distress nine days after diagnosis with SARS-CoV-2 infection. Examination with an endoscope revealed bilateral vocal cord paralysis, which is an immobility of both vocal cords found in the larynx or voice box. The researchers concluded that this paralysis was likely a downstream effect of the COVID-19 virus when an extensive workup revealed no other cause.

The case, which is presented December 19th in the journal Pediatrics, suggests that vocal cord paralysis may be a nervous system-related (neuropathic) complication of the virus, in addition to already well-established neurologic complications in children and adults.

“Given how common this virus is among children, this newly recognized potential complication should be considered in any child presenting with a breathing, talking or swallowing complaint after a recent COVID-19 diagnosis,” says first author Danielle Reny Larrow, M.D., a resident in the Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery at Mass Eye and Ear. “This is especially important as such complaints could be easily attributed to more common diagnoses such as asthma.”

While at the hospital, the patient underwent a detailed battery of diagnostic tests from Mass General Brigham clinicians including blood work, imaging, cerebrospinal fluid analysis and consultations with otolaryngology, neurology, psychiatry, speech language pathology and neurosurgery.

When speech therapy failed to relieve the patient’s symptoms, the physicians performed a tracheostomy-a surgically created opening in the windpipe – to relieve the patient’s breathing difficulties. She remained tracheostomy-dependent for more than 13 months after initial treatment, suggesting that this type of nerve complication may not be temporary.

Following the submission of this case report, the physicians were able to remove the tracheostomy-15 months after it was inserted and just in time for the patient’s high school graduation and prom.

“She was having her senior prom a year and a quarter to the date of when she lost her function, and she told me she was not going to go to the prom with her tracheostomy in place,” says Hartnick. “We decided to intervene so that she could graduate high school and go to her prom tracheostomy-free, which she did.”

Post-viral neuropathy is a known cause of vocal cord paralysis, and there have been several reports of paralysis in one or both vocal cords of adults as a complication of SARS-CoV-2 infection, but this is the first report of the complication in an adolescent. This is important, the authors say, because these types of complications are not usually expected in young, healthy individuals and there have been more than 15 million reported cases of pediatric SARS-CoV-2 infection.

“To have a young, healthy, vibrant high schooler all of a sudden lose one of their important cranial nerves such that they can’t breathe is highly unusual and took some parsing,” says senior author Christopher Hartnick, M.D., director of the Division of Pediatric Otolaryngology and Pediatric Airway, Voice, and Swallowing Center at Mass Eye and Ear. “The fact that kids can actually have long term neurotrophic effects from COVID-19 is something that it’s important for the broader pediatric community to be aware of in order to be able to treat our kids well.”

Reference:

Larrow DR, Hartnick C. Bilateral Vocal Cord Paralysis Requiring Long-term Tracheostomy After SARS-CoV-2 Infection. Pediatrics. 2023 Dec 19:e2023061897. doi: 10.1542/peds.2023-061897. 

Powered by WPeMatico

Repetitive Concussions linked to Suicidal Behaviors Among Young Males

In a recent study, the underexplored nexus between repetitive concussions and mental health were the point of focus were the study team found a concerning association between multiple concussions and nonfatal suicidal behaviors among youth. Using data from the National Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System, this retrospective cross-sectional survey involved 28,442 secondary school students across the United States.

The research by Jacob Kay investigated the correlation between self-reported concussion frequency and adverse mental health outcomes by looking into the most overlooked aspect of how this relationship might differ between male and female youth. With growing interest surrounding the impact of concussions on mental health, especially in sports, the gender-specific implications remain less explored.

And so, utilizing a comprehensive set of variables, including self-reported concussions, feelings of sadness or hopelessness, and suicidal behaviors, the study revealed a significant finding. Students reporting two or more concussions in the past 12 months were at substantially higher odds of reporting suicidal attempts compared to those with a single concussion (adjusted odds ratio = 2.03; 95% CI = 1.43, 2.88). However, a crucial nuance emerged in the analysis of sex interactions and suggests that this heightened risk was predominantly driven by males. Among females, the strength of associations did not escalate with an increased frequency of concussions.

The implications of this study signal that adolescents with a history of concussions are at an high risk of poor mental health and suicidal behaviors. Also, the link between an increased number of concussions and significantly greater odds of reporting suicidal attempts is particularly noteworthy among males. The study underscores the urgent need for healthcare professionals to closely monitor the mental health of adolescents, regardless of gender with experience of repetitive concussions, especially those occurring in close temporal proximity. 

Reference:

Kay, J. J. M., Coffman, C. A., Harrison, A., Tavakoli, A. S., Torres-McGehee, T. M., Broglio, S. P., & Moore, R. D. (2023). Concussion Exposure and suicidal ideation, planning, and attempts among US high school students. Journal of Athletic Training, 58(9), 751–758. https://doi.org/10.4085/1062-6050-0117.22

Powered by WPeMatico

Benzodiazepines discontinuation tied to higher risk of death in long-term users: JAMA

USA: Benzodiazepine discontinuation may be associated with unanticipated harms among patients prescribed for stable long-term treatment, a recent study published in JAMA Network Open has revealed.

The researchers suggest that efforts to promote discontinuation should carefully consider the potential discontinuation risks relative to continuation.

The comparative effectiveness study among 353 576 patients receiving stable long-term treatment with benzodiazepines revealed that discontinuation was tied to small absolute increases in mortality and other potential harms, including suicide attempts, nonfatal overdose, suicidal ideation, and emergency department visits.

There has been a rise in increases in overdose deaths involving benzodiazepines over the past several years, leading to several FDA actions including a 2016 warning related to co-prescribing with opioids and a 2020 class-wide boxed warning about the risks of misuse, abuse, physical dependence, addiction, and withdrawal reactions.

The FDA has also developed an evidence-based clinical practice guideline for the safe tapering of benzodiazepines. However, no studies have investigated the risks of discontinuation. Therefore, Donovan T. Maust, Department of Psychiatry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, and colleagues aimed to identify the association of benzodiazepine discontinuation with mortality and other adverse events in patients prescribed stable long-term benzodiazepine therapy, stratified by baseline opioid exposure.

The researchers assessed claims data from Optum on patients (mean age 62 years) with a benzodiazepine prescription from 2013 to 2019, totalling 213,011 without concomitant opioids and 140,565 with opioids. Benzodiazepine discontinuation was defined as no benzodiazepine prescription prescription for 31 consecutive days during 6 months after baseline. Patients were followed for about 1 year after baseline benzodiazepine prescriptions.

The primary outcome was mortality during 12 months of follow-up. Secondary outcomes included suicide attempts or self-inflicted injury, nonfatal overdose, emergency department use, and suicidal ideation.

The study led to the following findings:

  • Among the nonopioid exposed, the adjusted cumulative incidence of death after one year was 5.5% for discontinuers, an absolute risk difference of 2.1 percentage points higher than for nondiscontinuers.
  • The mortality risk was 1.6 times that of nondiscontinuers.
  • Among those with opioid exposure, the adjusted cumulative incidence of death was 6.3% for discontinuers, an absolute risk difference of 2.4 percentage points higher than for nondiscontinuers and a mortality risk 1.6 times that of nondiscontinuers.
  • The cumulative incidence of secondary outcomes was also higher among discontinuers.

The researchers identified small absolute increases in the risk of harm among patients with stable long-term prescription benzodiazepine treatment who appear to discontinue than in those continuing treatment, including those with and without recent prescription opioid exposure.

“Given questions raised about the safety of benzodiazepine discontinuation among stable long-term users, clinicians should be judicious in initiating new prescriptions and carefully limit conversion to long-term use,” the researchers concluded.

Reference:

Maust DT, Petzold K, Strominger J, Kim HM, Bohnert ASB. Benzodiazepine Discontinuation and Mortality Among Patients Receiving Long-Term Benzodiazepine Therapy. JAMA Netw Open. 2023;6(12):e2348557. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.48557

Powered by WPeMatico

Engineers develop a vibrating, ingestible capsule that might help treat obesity

When you eat a large meal, your stomach sends signals to your brain that create a feeling of fullness, which helps you realize it’s time to stop eating. A stomach full of liquid can also send these messages, which is why dieters are often advised to drink a glass of water before eating.

MIT engineers have now come up with a new way to take advantage of that phenomenon, using an ingestible capsule that vibrates within the stomach. These vibrations activate the same stretch receptors that sense when the stomach is distended, creating an illusory sense of fullness.

In animals who were given this pill 20 minutes before eating, the researchers found that this treatment not only stimulated the release of hormones that signal satiety, but also reduced the animals’ food intake by about 40 percent. Scientists have much more to learn about the mechanisms that influence human body weight, but if further research suggests this technology could be safely used in humans, such a pill might offer a minimally invasive way to treat obesity, the researchers say.

“For somebody who wants to lose weight or control their appetite, it could be taken before each meal,” says Shriya Srinivasan PhD ’20, a former MIT graduate student and postdoc who is now an assistant professor of bioengineering at Harvard University. “This could be really interesting in that it would provide an option that could minimize the side effects that we see with the other pharmacological treatments out there.”

Srinivasan is the lead author of the new study, which appears today in Science Advances. Giovanni Traverso, an associate professor of mechanical engineering at MIT and a gastroenterologist at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, is the senior author of the paper.

A sense of fullness

When the stomach becomes distended, specialized cells called mechanoreceptors sense that stretching and send signals to the brain via the vagus nerve. As a result, the brain stimulates production of insulin, as well as hormones such as C-peptide, Pyy, and GLP-1. All of these hormones work together to help people digest their food, feel full, and stop eating. At the same time, levels of ghrelin, a hunger-promoting hormone, go down.

While a graduate student at MIT, Srinivasan became interested in the idea of controlling this process by artificially stretching the mechanoreceptors that line the stomach, through vibration. Previous research had shown that vibration applied to a muscle can induce a sense that the muscle has stretched farther than it actually has.

“I wondered if we could activate stretch receptors in the stomach by vibrating them and having them perceive that the entire stomach has been expanded, to create an illusory sense of distension that could modulate hormones and eating patterns,” Srinivasan says.

As a postdoc in MIT’s Koch Institute for Integrative Cancer Research, Srinivasan worked closely with Traverso’s lab, which has developed many novel approaches to oral delivery of drugs and electronic devices. For this study, Srinivasan, Traverso, and a team of researchers designed a capsule about the size of a multivitamin, that includes a vibrating element. When the pill, which is powered by a small silver oxide battery, reaches the stomach, acidic gastric fluids dissolve a gelatinous membrane that covers the capsule, completing the electronic circuit that activates the vibrating motor.

In a study in animals, the researchers showed that once the pill begins vibrating, it activates mechanoreceptors, which send signals to the brain through stimulation of the vagus nerve. The researchers tracked hormone levels during the periods when the device was vibrating and found that they mirrored the hormone release patterns seen following a meal, even when the animals had fasted.

The researchers then tested the effects of this stimulation on the animals’ appetite. They found that when the pill was activated for about 20 minutes, before the animals were offered food, they consumed 40 percent less, on average, than they did when the pill was not activated. The animals also gained weight more slowly during periods when they were treated with the vibrating pill.

“The behavioral change is profound, and that’s using the endogenous system rather than any exogenous therapeutic. We have the potential to overcome some of the challenges and costs associated with delivery of biologic drugs by modulating the enteric nervous system,” Traverso says.

The current version of the pill is designed to vibrate for about 30 minutes after arriving in the stomach, but the researchers plan to explore the possibility of adapting it to remain in the stomach for longer periods of time, where it could be turned on and off wirelessly as needed. In the animal studies, the pills passed through the digestive tract within four or five days.

The study also found that the animals did not show any signs of obstruction, perforation, or other negative impacts while the pill was in their digestive tract.

An alternative approach

This type of pill could offer an alternative to the current approaches to treating obesity, the researchers say. Nonmedical interventions such as diet exercise don’t always work, and many of the existing medical interventions are fairly invasive. These include gastric bypass surgery, as well as gastric balloons, which are no longer used widely in the United States due to safety concerns.

Drugs such as GLP-1 agonists can also aid weight loss, but most of them have to be injected, and they are unaffordable for many people. According to Srinivasan, the MIT capsules could be manufactured at a cost that would make them available to people who don’t have access to more expensive treatment options.

“For a lot of populations, some of the more effective therapies for obesity are very costly. At scale, our device could be manufactured at a pretty cost-effective price point,” she says. “I’d love to see how this would transform care and therapy for people in global health settings who may not have access to some of the more sophisticated or expensive options that are available today.”

The researchers now plan to explore ways to scale up the manufacturing of the capsules, which could enable clinical trials in humans. Such studies would be important to learn more about the devices’ safety, as well as determine the best time to swallow the capsule before to a meal and how often it would need to be administered.

Reference:

Shriya S. Srinivasan et al. ,A vibrating ingestible bioelectronic stimulator modulates gastric stretch receptors for illusory satiety.Sci. Adv.9,eadj3003(2023).DOI:10.1126/sciadv.adj3003.

Powered by WPeMatico

Doctor punches patient during surgery, suspended

Chinese authorities are investigating an incident where a surgeon is alleged to have punched a patient during an operation, as shown in a viral video without a specified date. The hospital’s parent company, Aier China, has suspended the surgeon, and the hospital’s CEO, where the 2019 incident occurred, has been dismissed. The video appears to depict the surgeon, performing eye surgery, punching the patient’s head multiple times, with two others present in the operating room.

Aier China, a chain of eye hospitals, confirmed the incident at its Guigang hospital, involving an 82-year-old woman who experienced discomfort during surgery due to local anesthesia. The patient, who spoke a local dialect, reportedly did not respond to warnings in Mandarin, leading the surgeon to act roughly in what was described as an emergency situation. Local authorities noted injuries to the patient’s forehead.

For more news & updates, check out the link given below:

https://medicaldialogues.in/

Powered by WPeMatico

Disclosure of assets of members: NMC expresses its reservations to Health Ministry

Amid the rising pressure to make the details of the assets and liabilities of the NMC Chairman and members public, the National Medical Commission (NMC) has expressed its ‘reservations’ in this regard.

Writing to the Under Secretary of the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW), the Commission has mentioned about the reservations for uploading some of the personal information of the officers including the details of lands, jewellery, investments in banks/ financial institutions/ insurance policy i.e. numbers, addresses etc.

For more details, check out the link given below:

Disclosure Of Assets Of Members: NMC Expresses Its Reservations To Health Ministry

Powered by WPeMatico

AstraZeneca Gets CDSCO Panel Nod for Enhertu 100mg for additional indication of breast cancer

New Delhi: Noting an unmet medical need in the country, the Subject Expert Committee (SEC) functional under the Central Drug Standard Control Organisation (CDSCO) has approved AstraZeneca’s Trastuzumab deruxtecan concentrate solution for infusion 100mg (Enhertu 100mg) for the treatment of adult patients with unresectable or metastatic HER2-Low (IHC 1+ or IHC 2+/ISH-) breast cancer who have received a prior systemic therapy in the metastatic setting or developed disease recurrence during or within 6 months of completing adjuvant chemotherapy.

This came after the firm presented the proposal for approval of additional indication for Trastuzumab Deruxtecan Powder for Concentrate for Solution for Infusion(Enhertu 100mg) i.e. “for the treatment of adult patients with unresectable or metastatic HER2-Low (IHC 1+ or IHC 2+/ISH-) breast cancer who have received a prior systemic therapy in the metastatic setting or developed disease recurrence during or within 6 months of completing adjuvant chemotherapy.”

The firm continued that the proposal is for patients with hormone receptor-positive (HR+) breast cancer who should additionally have received or be ineligible for endocrine therapy under the category of life-threatening and unmet needs in the country.

In addition to the above, the firm requested for a waiver of the local clinical trial.

Trastuzumab is a monoclonal antibody against human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2). Trastuzumab binds to an extracellular domain of this receptor and inhibits HER2 homodimerization, thereby preventing HER2-mediated signaling.

Trastuzumab is a biologic agent primarily used in the treatment of HER2-positive breast cancer. It may be used as adjuvant therapy for localized disease or as first-line therapy for metastatic disease. After trastuzumab deruxtecan binds to HER2 found on malignant cells, it is internalized and linker cleavage occurs through the actions of lysosomal enzymes. After it is released through cleavage, deruxtecan (DXd) causes targeted DNA damage and apoptosis in cancer cells, due to the ability to cross cell membranes.

In the recent SEC meeting for oncology and hematology held on 7th and 8th December 2023, the firm presented the results of clinical studies conducted in other countries.

The committee noted that the proposed indication of the drug is approved in other countries including the US, EU, and Canada and there is unmet medical need in the country for the proposed indication.

After detailed deliberation, the committee recommended the approval of the proposed additional indication with a local clinical trial waiver.

Also Read: Roche gets CDSCO panel nod to study Crovalimab

Powered by WPeMatico

Patient Dies After Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy: Private Hospital, Surgeon Held Negligent, Slapped Rs 5 Lakh Compensation

Panchkula: Holding a private hospital and its attending surgeon guilty of medical negligence during a laparoscopic surgery that resulted in the death of a patient, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (DCDRC) recently directed them to pay Rs 5 lakh compensation to his wife.

The consumer court issued the order after relying on the expert committee inquiry report mentioning that there was an error on the part of the treating doctor while handling the complications, which resulted during the Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy.

Apart from this, the bench also directed the multi-speciality hospital to ensure the availability of a team of experts belonging to different medical field and noted, “Before parting with this order, we deem it proper to direct the OP No.1, who claims itself to be a multiple-specialty hospital, to ensure the availability of team of experts belonging to different medical field, in appropriate cases, prior to conducting of any surgical operation so as to tackle the emergent complications arising during the operation and accordingly, the OPs No.1 & 2 are directed to ensure that the team of an expert belonging to different medical field is arranged while conducting any surgical operation in future.”

The matter goes back to 2017 when the complainant’s husband was suffering from pain in the abdomen and after diagnosis, his gall bladder was found distended showing multiple calculi in his lumen measuring 3 mm to 4 mm in size. In this regard, a report was prepared by Jindal Diagnostic Centre, Ram Nagar, National Highway, Kalka.

Consequently, the patient was admitted to the treating hospital for Elective Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy and during the surgery, he suffered Biliovascular injury on the operation table, and the Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy was converted to open Cholecystectomy.

Since the treating facility was unable to manage the case, the patient was referred to PGI Chandigarh with an open abdomen with 7 vascular clamps in situ. The complainant alleged that the treating facility in a very casual and negligent manner referred the complainant’s husband of the complainant to PGI without providing proper medical facility. 

Allegedly, due to the deteriorating condition of the patient, he was re-operated in PGI Chandigarh on 28.05.2017 and after the operation, he was kept in the ICU as his condition was not stable and ultimately he expired on 30.07.2017 in PGI Chandigarh.

The complainant submitted that during the treatment at PGI, Chandigarh, the concerned doctors at the facility observed that the patient had sustained major Biliovascular injury and Duodenal Injury during his attempted Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy. The reason for the patient’s death was given by the PGI doctors as cardiac arrest and the Major Biliovascular injury with Duodenal injury status post attempted Laparoscopic converted open Cholecystectomy.

Referring to this, the complainant filed a consumer complaint and alleged that the doctor, who conducted the surgery, did not have the required qualifications to conduct the surgical operation through Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy method. It was alleged that it was the duty of the concerned doctor, who is also the management of the hospital, to arrange a team of experts having requisite qualifications, and wide experience so as to handle any complications, which might arise during the operation.

On the other hand, the doctor and the hospital referred to the wide experience of the treating doctor and submitted that after commencing the surgery, the treating doctor visualized a bunch of venous Plexus around the Cystic Duct and Common Bile Duct (CBD). 

It was also submitted that plexus are generally of two types i.e. Venous Plexous and Arterial Plexus and the walls of Arterial Plexus are strong and thick, whereas the walls of venous Plexus are very thin and can easily bleed. The bleeding from Arterial Plexus is in showers and one could see the source of bleeding and bleeding can be immediately stopped by surgical maneuvers i.e. by ligating, cauterizing, clamping etc. but bleeding from venous Plexus is diffused and, many a times, source of bleeding is uncertain. Plexus is a complex network of vessels and nerves and plexus may be normal or abnormal.

They submitted that in the patient’s case, the plexus was unusual and abnormal and the doctor saw such type of phlexus for the first time. They claimed that this type of plexus cannot be figured out pre-operatively through ultrasound in a routine investigation for Gall Bladder Stones. It was further submitted that when the doctor caught hold of Gall Bladder, a sudden spurt of profuse bleeding started. Therefore, he immediately stopped the laparoscopic procedure and the patient’s abdomen was opened instantly. However, since the bleeding was uncontrollable and the profused and source of bleeding could not be ascertained and the treating facility, the doctor did all the maneuvers to stop the bleeding i.e. sponging, suturing with pressure and arterial clamps were applied(metalled instruments), and the bleeding stopped.

After the bleeding stopped completely and the blood pressure started rising, the doctor kept the clamp, put gauge and referred him to PGI Chandigarh urgently in a stable condition for further management. 

They also pointed out that an inquiry was conducted by three doctors at the Civil Hospital, Panchkula and the concerned committee never opined that there was medical negligence or unfair trade practice by the doctor. The panel opined that the patient’s case was the rarest of rare cases and held that there was a mistake on the doctor’s and hospital’s part while handling complications during Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy.

While considering the matter, the consumer court took note of the enquiry report and also the case summary issued by PGI Chandigarh and noted that these documents mentioned that the patient sustained the Major Biliovascular Injury with Duodental Injury, during his attempted Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy by treating doctor, on 27.05.2017.

“As per the said Enquiry Committee report dated 08.11.2017(Annexure C-5), the cause of death of Sh. Karam Chand(now deceased) was the Major Biliovascular Injury with Duodental Injury, which he had sustained during his attempted Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy by OP No.2, on 27.05.2017,” noted the Commission.

The consumer court noted that the inquiry committee gave its findings under the heading of “comments” in three paras. The Committee observed that it was a rarest of rare cases. 

“It was also observed in the first para that 5-6 complications had arisen simultaneously during the Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy conducted at (OP No.1) on 27.05.2017. However, the Enquiry Committee, taking into consideration all the relevant factors, which were placed before it, has concluded in an unambiguous terms that there was an error on the part of OP No.2, while handling the complications, which had arisen during the Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy. As per said report of the Enquiry Committee, a surgeon having 30 years of experience was not expected to commit such kind of error/mistake, while handling complications. The Enquiry Committee in the last para of its findings has found that the services rendered by OPs No.1 & 2, while shifting Sh.Karam Chand(now deceased) from to PGI, Chandigarh were unsatisfactory,” the Commission observed.

Referring to the inquiry committee report, the Commission noted, “Pertinently, the Enquiry Committee has given its report dated 08.11.2017(Annexure C-5) after giving due consideration to the respective submissions made before it by the complainant as well as OP No.2; thus, the submissions made by the learned counsel for Ops No.1 & 2 in the present complaint are not tenable.”

“We find force and substance in the submissions of the complainant that the OP No.1, who claims to be a had failed to arrange the team of experts prior to the starting of Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy on 27.05.2017 so as to tackle the emergent health situation and complications, if any, arising out during the operation. The OP No.1, who claims itself to be a starting of Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy on, 27.05.2017, so as to tackle the emergent health situation and complications,” it further observed.

Therefore, the Commission directed the hospital and doctor to pay Rs 5 lakh compensation to the complainant. They were also directed to pay Rs 6,000 to the complainant along with interest @ 9% per annum(simple interest) w.e.f. 27.05.2017 i.e. the date of payment made by the complainant to the hospital till its realization. Further, they were slapped with Rs 7,500 as litigation charges.

To view the order, click on the link below:

https://medicaldialogues.in/pdf_upload/medical-negligence-j-n-shory-228008.pdf

Also Read: Delay in treatment of cancer patient leading to death: GTB hospital, doctors held negligent, slapped Rs 5 lakh compensation

Powered by WPeMatico